You Can See Everything; Elizabeth Holmes; Nathan Fielder; Psychoanalysis; Psychology; Documentary; Thomas Ogden; W.R.D.Fairbairn; Applied Psychoanalysis; Documentary; Billy Evans, Amanda Seyfried.
The reluctant wife went to see You Can See Everything at a
matinee this week. When my class in
psychodynamic psychotherapy insisted that I see it this weekend so that we
could talk about it in class next week, the reluctant wife graciously agreed to
join me for a re-viewing on Saturday followed by dinner where she uncharacteristically
stated that she wanted to process the film (she generally dislikes things like
book clubs where people discuss experiences they have shared because they feel
to her like opportunities for people to bloviate about their own experiences
rather than to learn from each other’s).
After the film, not only did we talk about it in the car on
the way home to walk the dog, where we talked about her take on it, we talked
about it in the car on the way to the restaurant, where we talked about my take
on it, and then, in the restaurant we puzzled over it a bit more, came to an
agreement, and then, that night, after I fell asleep, she pursued reading about
the enigmatic ending, and she told me at breakfast about the ways that her
reading had supported our shared position.
The documentary and re-enactment film You Can See Everything
is a highly edited set of interactions between Nathan Fielder, a
very smart, penetrating interviewer best known for his provocative interactions
with people he believes to be con men by outconning them, and Elizabeth Holmes,
the entrepreneurial founder of Theranos, a billion dollar health enterprise
that went up in smoke when its claims to be able to diagnose multiple aspects
of physical health from a single drop of the patient’s blood proved to be untrue. The rest of this post will contain multiple
spoilers; reading further will interfere with some of the pleasure of
discovering the unfolding of the film and the central dilemma, but will also, I
hope, prepare you, as the first viewing prepared my wife, to look at the film
with a discerning eye, or to help you reflect on it having seen it already.
The initial interviews take place in 2023 in an ocean side house
that Elizabeth has rented with her partner, Billy
Evans. They and their two
children, a newborn and a child maybe two years old, invite Fielder and a camera
crew to take up residence in this, their temporary home, and promise Fielder that he can see everything
in the 34 days before Holmes' imprisonment in a Federal Prison for charges stemming
from defrauding investors in Theranos.
After she is imprisoned, Fielder appears to be
haunted by Evans and pursues getting to know more about her while she is in
prison. He visits with Billy in the
couple’s home in Texas, and hires on Amanda Seyfried,
who portrayed Holmes in the TV drama The
Dropout.
Seyfried becomes his interlocutor as he puzzles with her who Holmes
actually is, and she also portrays Holmes in various reenactments of
interactions between Fielder and Holmes that can’t be recorded because she is
in Federal Prison.
The film’s ending is the place that my wife picked up on as
critical to what came to be our shared understanding of the film. In the final scene, a previous shot of
two people in the ocean at the San Diego beach house, originally shown from a
distance (and presumed by us to be a shot, like many of them walking together,
of Elizabeth and Billy), is zoomed in on and revealed to be a shot of Elizabeth
and Nathan swimming together, something that Nathan, earlier, begged off doing,
both because it would be cold and because it would cross some sort of line –
perhaps the line of swimming in cold water, but also perhaps the line of
becoming personally engaged with the subject of a documentary.
The penultimate scene immediately before it is a discussion between Seyfried
and Nathan in which she wonders whether Nathan is protecting Elizabeth. He asks why she thinks that, and she says, “It’s
complicated,” and we cut to the swimming scene and then cut to black.
My brilliant wife’s thesis is that Nathan is signaling that
what we have seen is not all that can be seen, but all that he is willing to
show. More centrally, what we have seen
is what Nathan wants or chooses to show after having seen whatever it is that he has seen.
After the blackout apparent end, we see that Nathan returns to a line from a New York Times
article that quotes Elizabeth as having created herself as a character. Whether she has done that or not, Nathan
certainly has done so.
The brilliant wife’s relatively benign interpretation is that
Nathan is signalling that anything we see in the media has been processed through multiple filters.
We are never seeing the capital T truth, we are seeing aspects of the truth. We are not seeing things as they actually are – but instead are seeing
highly edited versions of reality. This
starts with the ways that people filter who they are as others view them, and
ends with editors choosing which glance, which view, to provide. So when we are given a view of Billy showering,
including his ample endowment, this is something that Billy has wanted us to
view, something that Nathan wants us to see, and something that tells us
something, but the question is what it tells us about whom.
I think this is an important truth that we are coming to grips with in the general country. There is no such thing as an objective truth - or perhaps even objectivity. But that doesn't mean that anything goes. Authorities have to act on what is known at the moment, but what is known will always be impacted by who we are and it will shift and change across time as we and others weigh in and provide alternative viewpoints.
Following my wife’s lead, I will interpret the film as a possible
description of Nathan’s psychology. This
may be useful in thinking about the ways that Elizabeth impacted others and may
be part of the reason she was able to bring them under her sway. It will then, necessarily be a description of
Elizabeth’s psychology, but only through the lens of Nathan’s eye, camera, and
editing tools after Elizabeth has gone through whatever process she does to present herself to Nathan. I will use Thomas Ogden’s reading of
W.R.D. Fairbairn’s
psychology to do this (Ogden is a contemporary psychoanalyst and Fairbairn wrote
in the 1940s – This is drawn from Ogden’s book Creative Readings: Essays on
Seminal Analytic Works).
This reading is not intended to be definitive. It is one perspective, just as Fielder’s
perspective on Elizabeth is one perspective.
It will sound definitive and will talk about causes, but I think that we
need to be careful about that. These
are, as Ogden emphasizes, metaphors for how the mind works, just as Freud’s Ego,
Id, and Superego were metaphors, not actual structures. The usefulness of the metaphors will be
determined by the aptness of the reading – and by whether they further your
ability to think about Nathan, Elizabeth, Billy, and Amanda, but also me, my
wife, Tom and WRD and most importantly, you and the people in your life and in
your mind.
Fairbairn imagined that we are traumatized, when we are
infants, that our cries don’t always bring a caregiver to give us care. We can’t care for ourselves, and, when the
caregiver is unavailable to us, we panic.
Of course, much of the time, when we cry, a caregiver does emerge who
provides for our needs. Our Core Self –
one that stays more or less attuned to what is going on around us – relegates the
drama of sometimes being attended to and sometimes not to an internal theater. This theater allows us to play out the life
and death drama of being cared for and not in our minds, where we can control
the players, rather than being subject to what goes on out there in the real
world, a place where it becomes increasingly apparent that we exert little actual influence over the
players.
Fairbairn suggests that we create four basic players to
manage the state of intermittent deprivation.
The first of these he calls the Exciting Object – the one that we
desire. This would be the caregiver that
would show up at the first sign of distress.
For a moment, let’s imagine her, in the spirit of Nathan, as Elizabeth –
a character rather than a person. Always
available, she promises that we can see everything. She will always be available, completely
open, and totally without guile.
Not surprisingly, we desire the Exciting Object – and the
part of our mind that emerges to do this Fairbairn calls the Libidinal Ego, which
we could think of as the desiring part of ourselves. In the drama that Elizabeth and Nathan have
created, this part would be played by Billy, who fell in love with Elizabeth in
the first hour of their conversation at a party and has stayed unwaveringly in
love with her ever since, even after learning that she was the woman who had bilked people out of a billion dollars, and even now that she is headed into federal prison with massive debt. When Nathan interrogates Billy's love, Billy suddenly remembers that he has to be elsewhere. Later, when meeting with Nathan and Amanda
while Elizabeth is in prison, Billy recounts what a tremendous lover he is (while
noting that he hasn’t had sex in 899 days – he is faithful to his love who is
not allowed conjugal visits). He is also portrayed as an unstable person - and characterized as a narcissist by Amanda. Of course, Narcissus fell in love with his reflection - is Elizabeth simply Billy's inner Exciting Object?
But all is not goodness and light in our souls. There is also the part that hangs onto the
panic of the times that our cries went unheeded. Fairbairn calls this part the Rejecting Object
(though Ogden suggests he should have called it the Rejecting Subject – it is a
part of ourselves – if a part that we hate).
We imagine that it is we who have rejected us – to take away some of the
sting of being rejected by the unresponsive ones in the world. Amanda seems to play this part in the
drama. Elizabeth complains that it is
Amanda’s portrayal of her that has caused the other inmates to reject her – and
Amanda shoots back that it is Elizabeth’s actions are the problem, while also playing
Elizabeth in the recreated scene, clarifying that she (and we) are not just a
single character in this drama, but capable of playing multiple roles.
Fairbairn’s final character in our internal drama is the Internal
Saboteur. This character, like Nathan
Fielder, is bonded to the Rejecting Object by allying with it, and it aggressively
attacks (or, in Fielder’s case interrogates) the Exciting Object. The Internal Saboteur claims that the Exciting Object (Elizabeth)
is not really all that the Libidinal Ego (Billy) claims it to be. It doesn’t really love us (Nathan) – it is inconstant,
and – and here’s the really interesting Fairbairnian twist – our love for the
Exciting Object is what causes the Exciting Object to reject us. Our love is somehow poisonous. The Internal Saboteur is faithful to the Rejecting Object because that Object is at least authentic and reliable.
If, at this point, you are feeling that this is a really
bleak summation of the human condition, you are doing a good job of following
this convoluted path. Ogden does a nice
job in his chapter of describing how this helps us know how to treat this (human) condition so that we can spend more time in the unsullied original state of the
Core Self and less time mired in this dramatic quagmire, but that is not the focus
of the movie, so I will stay with the movie.
If these four characters; Nathan, Elizabeth, Billy, and
Amanda, are players in an intrapsychic drama – a drama of the mind – then Elizabeth’s
parents, who make two appearances, play the part of reality. They show up at the beach house for a minute,
and then again in the Texas house the day that Elizabeth is incarcerated.
At the beach house, Nathan asks Elizabeth’s Dad how it came
to be that Elizabeth developed into the person who duped so many people. The father, who had, ironically, worked at
Enron, another corporation that vanished into smoke, and who seemed to be a
cautious man, noted that Elizabeth was changed by the rape (Whoa, where did that
come from? Why was it not interrogated,
followed up on, or mentioned again), and went on to blame her lover before
Billy and the president of Theranos.
On the occasion of both visits, Elizabeth’s mother was quiet. She appeared to be concerned, but inert. If we were to think of her in Fairbairn’s
terms, it wouldn’t be hard to think of her as the caregiver who was present,
but not providing what was needed, which could well have been interpreted as
rejection.
So, are we, analytically to blame the mother? Is that where psychoanalysts always end up? What about Elizabeth appearing to be on the
spectrum? What about the possibility that
Elizabeth’s stare is the result of a dissociative state that might be secondary
to sexual or physical trauma, perhaps starting at an early age? Somehow we have shifted our perspective, not
surprisingly, onto Elizabeth, even though we set out to explore Nathan’s mind.
In so far as Nathan is playing the role of the Internal
Saboteur, he is bound to Elizabeth because she, in all her goodness and light,
is the Exciting Object. And if Nathan crossed
an ethical line in being in contact with Elizabeth, in Amanda’s words, if he
came to be her protector rather than her interlocutor, haven’t we learned
something about the way that Elizabeth was able to be a character in other
people’s dramas – regardless of how she came to play that character in her life
and in this documentary?
We can hardly blame Nathan. In Fairbairn's conceptualization, the Internal Saboteur and the Rejecting Object have only very shadowy existences that are contingent on the Exciting Object not being all that she appears to be. They live in a dark and lonely corner of the soul. Nathan and Amanda are making this film not about themselves, but about Elizabeth. They are dependent on her. When Billy negotiates to be paid to be the subject of a documentary - a highly unusual arrangement - Nathan has to acknowledge that, since shooting has already started - there are already considerable sunk costs - Billy holds all the leverage. Nathan's shadowy existence is, indeed, dependent on the subject of his interrogation.
Nathan’s protection of Elizabeth comes in the form of describing
her “problem” being using language too literally – saying that her product can
do something, meaning that, in theory, it is able to do that, rather than that
it will, in its present form, actually do this.
He marshals her concrete reaction to the classic “Who’s on First” sketch
as evidence that she is remarkably concrete in her thinking about language. She wasn't duping anyone! She is an Exciting Object who is real, not ephemeral! She is genuinely all goodness and light!
We also witness Nathan lose his “objective” position as he
learns that Billy is representing Elizabeth, both with images and with words,
while she is locked in prison and unable to see the language that he is using. When he, as Internal Saboteur, tries to
distance her from Billy, she blithely restates her undying love and complete
acceptance of Billy, rejecting Nathan and his efforts to save her. Damn, Nathan is once again relegated to being the ghostly figure revolving around the "true" lovers at the center of this drama. Amanda's concerns and criticism - including of Nathan - should stand. Indeed, they should be put front and center, like the fart of her horse.
Whether Elizabeth has been a free subject who chose her
first partner as the president of her company and chose Billy to be her promoter
in her current effort to reboot Theranos or whether she is the victim of two
(or maybe many more) opportunistic men remains, for me, an open question. What seems clear to me is that Nathan,
perhaps wanting to slip from the Internal Saboteur Role into the Libidinal Ego
role – perhaps, in part, out of outrage but also jealousy over Billy’s access
to Elizabeth (we’ll have to wait to see if Amanda concurs with this), has largely presented Elizabeth in the role of the Exciting Object, but also left us uncertain of that. He is demonstrating his power - his existance - by showing her to be simply a character - not a true, complex, deep human being with multiple conflicting aspects that lead her to function in the way that she does - and he retains some semblance of corporality - he matters and she doesn't; she is trapped, not just in a Federal Prison, but in the prison of his mind, dependent on him to have a voice, dependent as she is depicted in the ocean, reaching towards him so he can pull her along, because she is helpless to swim on her own.
To access a narrative description of other posts on this site, link here. For a subject based index, link here.
To subscribe to posts (which occur 2-3 times per month), just enter your email in the subscribe by email box to the right of the text.

No comments:
Post a Comment